Top Shopify Multi-Vendor Apps: Shipturtle vs Puppet Vendors

One offers scalable options while the other has limited possibilities

Both Shipturtle & Puppet Vendors are used by entrepreneurs and businesses to manage their multivendor marketplaces on Shopify. However, PV is a pricey option (50% more than Shipturtle) with constraints in vendor management, order automation, and fulfillment processes.

Marketplace software overview

TRY SHIPTURTLE

TRY SHIPTURTLE

  • Multivendor Expertise
  • Scalable Solutions
  • Seamless Integration
  • Reliable Partner
Book A Demo

Criteria

Shipturtle

Puppet Vendors

Popularity
  • Unique B2C/C2C Modules with rental, service and product use cases.
  • Comprehensive order automation and 200+ shipping integrations.
  • Manage bulk actions: products, inventory, and orders easily.
  • Monitor user activity and manage payouts effectively.
  • Seamlessly connect to Shopify ecosystem.
  • More reviews on Shopify but limited multivendor functionality.
  • Lacks essential features like product templates and subscriptions.
  • Allows push notifications and staff account management options,
  • Provides vendor reminder features and merchant-vendor chat options.
  • Offers staff account management options.
  • Only offers support for product marketplaces.
  • Website Interface
  • Super fast with the latest design principles.
  • Designed for ease of use with a highly intuitive interface.
  • Can be installed as a PWA app for vendors, ensuring on-the-go management.
  • 'Vanilla' interface! Plus, 502 gateway error persists.
  • No dedicated mobile app limits its accessibility for vendors.
  • Offers whitelabel customization but the implementation is not as seamless as Shipturtle.
  • Product Management
  • Vendors can tailor product fields, create single or bulk listings & utilize templates for consistency.
  • Automatic inventory updates and quick edit options enhance efficiency.
  • Approval flows maintain quality control+ Support for product variants, custom fields and private label products.
  • Supports digital products, subscriptions and booking products.
  • Standard product management that fails to provide the same level of flexibility and efficiency as Shipturtle.
  • Ability to easily sync with seller websites lacking.
  • Basic product management with custom product fields, variants, and single product listings.
  • No bulk product management or quick-edit options, which could be limiting for large-scale marketplaces.
  • Order Management
  • Connect to 200+ shippers worldwide.
  • Let vendors set their own shipping rules.
  • Know where your order is at every step: Confirmed, In-transit or Delivered.
  • Customers can initiate returns directly.
  • Supports custom invoicing and return management.
  • Not suited for product marketplaces with complex shipping and OMS needs.
  • Limits order sync to 250 at a time. Forces vendors to track orders manually, leading to chaos.
  • We find it strange! Pretty sure, larger marketplaces will find it annoying too.
  • Lacks essential features like bulk processing and automation.
  • Better communication features (reminders, chat) for vendor fulfillment but that's not core!
  • The Shipturtle Advantage

    100%
    Go live in 48 hours
    5-10%
    Revenue Boost viz. Webhooks for Sync
    99.9%
    Accurate Inventory Sync
    400+
    Modules for B2C/C2C Marketplaces

    TRY SHIPTURTLE

    • Multivendor Expertise
    • Scalable Solutions
    • Seamless Integration
    • Reliable Partner
    Book A Demo

    Criteria

    Shipturtle

    Puppet Vendors

    Security, Scalability, and Support
  • Grow without limits with strong data security framework.
  • Manage user access and track changes with granular controls.
  • Open APIs allow you to integrate with other systems seamlessly.
  • Get help from our dedicated team 24/7
  • Basic security features like access control and data security:
  • But lacks advanced change logs and tracking.
  • Limited scalability with performance challenges.
  • Handling bulk product listings and large datasets is an issue.
  • Vendor Management
  • Manage vendors, track analytics, and communicate easily.
  • Sync with vendors on popular platforms like Shopify, Woocommerce, Magento, Squarespace, Amazon, etc.
  • Avoid overselling and underselling with instant sync and boost revenue by 5-10%.
  • Ensure accurate inventory and financial records.
  • 4-level vendor permissions and track performance.
  • Top vendor management features include vendor permissions, staff account management, and reminder tools for vendor coordination.
  • Lacks automation in vendor onboarding and inventory management.
  • Most customizations are possible only on a global level.
  • Payout Management
  • Integrate with any payment gateway.
  • Payouts to vendors via Stripe, PayPal, Razorpay out-of-box
  • Set commissions based on Product, Vendor, Category, or Global.
  • Manage payouts based on product, taxes, shipping, discounts, nd more.
  • Support both online and offline transactions.
  • Offers only basic payment integrations and offline tracking.
  • Lack of a clear flow of payments basis delivery and returns rule.
  • Vendors may struggle to keep track of what they're owed.
  • Pricing
  • Top tier plan at $179 per month (estimated for a marketplace receiving 5000 orders).
  • Guaranteed to go live within 2 days using out-of-the-box configurations.
  • Live chat assistance and a very knowledgeable team assist for scaling a marketplace, unrelated to the app!
  • Puppet Vendors' actual costs are much higher than advertised.
  • Consider their base price of USD 19 per month, the actual running costs typically reach around USD 127 per month, as additional features and support are often required.
  • Customers switching to Shipturtle save up to 50%.
  • Shipturtle lets you connect vendor websites, and automate listings, orders, shipping, payouts & much more. You can scale unlimited with open APIs for custom development.

    Enjoy 14-day free trial to experience its benefits firsthand.
    Install Now

    1000+ Marketplace Owners Shipturtle

    I am so impressed every day that I work with the Shipturtle team.

    "I am so impressed every day that I work with the Shipturtle team. I had a vision to launch a business that would include 3 different kinds of vendors: C2C sellers, small business vendors and on-demand printing/manufacturing vendors.  I was starting completely from scratch... I launched my business last month and they have been phenomenal in their customer care and support... They have gone above and beyond to help me succeed. I highly recommend working with Shipturtle."

    Nicole DeBoom

    eNDe project, United States

    Their customer service deserves 5 stars

    "The team at ShipTurtle is professional and always willing to help when I need it. They have done a lot of custom work for me, and broke my expectations for their custom capabilities. I would recommend their platform over all other marketplace apps on Shopify. Lastly, their customer service team deserves 5 stars."

    Jonathan Patterson
    PRX Market, United States

    They solved for my unique needs at an affordable price

    "... ShipTurtle worked with me to determine and create custom solutions for my business and was upfront about any associated costs... their customer service is very responsive... the integrations and automatic shipping tracking functionalities are incredibly convenient and useful... "

    Britney Gibilisco
    Localee, United States
    AriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logoAriseHealth logo

    Migrating to Shipturtle from Puppet Vendor is easy!

    Bulk excel upload | Minimum time | 360° onboarding support
    Start Free Trial